Middle+
What should be considered when interacting between C and C++ in the context of exception handling?
sobes.tech AI
Answer from AI
When interacting between C and C++ in the context of exception handling, the following should be considered:
- Crossing language boundaries. C++ exceptions cannot cross function boundaries with
extern "C"linkage. This leads to undefined behavior. - Incompatibility of mechanisms. C does not have a built-in exception handling mechanism (like
try-catchin C++), relying instead on error codes orsetjmp/longjmp. - Exception safety. C++ code calling C functions should be aware that these C functions may not be exception safe. They do not invoke destructors of local C++ objects when exiting via
longjmp. - Exception catching. C++
try-catchblocks should be used to handle C++ exceptions before calling C functions or after returning from them. - Error state transfer. C functions should return error codes that C++ code can then convert into exceptions if necessary.
- Callbacks. If C functions use C++ callbacks, these callbacks should catch any C++ exceptions internally to prevent exceptions from escaping through C code.
- Use of
noexcept. C++11 allows explicitly marking functions asnoexcept, which can be important when calling C functions or functions withextern "C", ensuring these functions do not throw exceptions.
An example demonstrating the crossing boundary problem:
#include <cstdio>
#include <stdexcept>
// C function declared with extern "C"
extern "C" {
void c_function(int value) {
if (value < 0) {
// Cannot throw an exception across C boundary!
// throw std::runtime_error("Negative value is not allowed in C.");
// Instead, C typically returns an error code or uses stderr
fprintf(stderr, "Error: Negative value is not allowed in C.\n");
}
// ... rest of the C function logic ...
}
// C++ function calling C function
void cpp_function() {
try {
// Call C function
c_function(10);
c_function(-5); // This call may lead to an error in the C function
} catch (const std::exception& e) {
// This catch block will not trigger if the C function throws an exception through extern "C"
printf("Caught exception in C++: %s\n", e.what());
}
}
}